Core Ontology for Petroleum Installations · INF-UFRGS-Ontologies · CNPq INF-UFRGS-ENERGIA inf.ufrgs.br/ontologies/copi dee69df

Cross-Standard Divergence Matrix

Divergences revealed by the five-step BFO/IOF-Core axiomatization method
⬇ Export LaTeX ← Workbench
83
T1
27% of 308 types
Categorical Placement
130
T2
42% of 308 types
Granularity
171
T3
56% of 308 types
Identity Criteria
9
T4
3% of 308 types
Topological vs. Mereological
259
T5
84% of 308 types
Implicit Function
Equipment Type T1
Categorical 		T2
Granularity 		T3
Identity 		T4
Topo vs Mero 		T5
Implicit Fn 		Actions
Absolute Pressure Transmitter COPI_0000205 Edit →
Absorber COPI_0000075 +1 Edit →
Accumulator COPI_0000206 +3 Edit →
Actuator COPI_0000207 +3 Edit →
Aerator Edit →
Agitator COPI_0000208 Edit →
Air Cooled Heat Exchanger COPI_0000209 Edit →
Analogue Temperature Indicator COPI_0000210 +1 Edit →
Angle Valve COPI_0000093 Edit →
Angle Valve Body COPI_0000211 Edit →
Anode COPI_0000212 +2 Edit →
Axial Displacement Transmitter COPI_0000213 Edit →
Ball Control Valve COPI_0000094 +1 Edit →
Ball Valve COPI_0000095 +2 Edit →
Basin COPI_0000214 +1 Edit →
Bearing COPI_0000215 Edit →
Bell Nipple COPI_0000216 +3 Edit →
Blanking Cap Pipe Union COPI_0000744 Edit →
Blind Flange COPI_0000745 Edit →
Block And Bleed Valve COPI_0000096 +1 Edit →
Blow Down Valve COPI_0000097 Edit →
Blower COPI_0000098 +2 Edit →
Boiler COPI_0000217 +2 Edit →
Bottom Hole Assembly COPI_0000218 Edit →
Brake COPI_0000219 +2 +1 Edit →
Burner COPI_0000220 Edit →
Butterfly Control Valve COPI_0000099 Edit →
Butterfly Valve COPI_0000100 +1 Edit →
Cable Tray COPI_0000221 +1 Edit →
Cap COPI_0000746 Edit →
Casing COPI_0000222 +3 Edit →
Cathodic Protection System COPI_0000223 +1 Edit →
Centrifugal Compressor COPI_0000101 +1 Edit →
Centrifugal Compressor Casing COPI_0000224 Edit →
Centrifugal Pump COPI_0000102 +2 Edit →
Centrifuge COPI_0000225 Edit →
Chamber COPI_0000722 Edit →
Check Valve COPI_0000103 Edit →
Check Valve Body COPI_0000226 Edit →
Check Valve Closure Member COPI_0000227 Edit →
Choke Control Valve COPI_0000104 Edit →
Choke Valve COPI_0000105 Edit →
Christmas Tree COPI_0000228 +1 +1 Edit →
Chromatograph COPI_0000229 Edit →
Circuit Breaker COPI_0000106 Edit →
Coalescent Filter COPI_0000750 Edit →
Coalescer COPI_0000107 Edit →
Compensator COPI_0000230 Edit →
Compressor COPI_0000073 +3 Edit →
Compressor Casing COPI_0000231 Edit →
Condenser COPI_0000232 Edit →
Conductivity Transmitter COPI_0000233 Edit →
Control Valve COPI_0000087 +2 Edit →
Controller COPI_0000234 +2 Edit →
Converter Edit →
Conveyor Edit →
Cooler COPI_0000235 Edit →
Cooling Tower COPI_0000236 +1 Edit →
Coriolis Mass Flow Meter COPI_0000237 Edit →
Coupling COPI_0000238 +1 Edit →
Damper COPI_0000239 +2 Edit →
Deaerator COPI_0000240 Edit →
Degasser COPI_0000241 +1 Edit →
Dehumidifier COPI_0000242 +1 Edit →
Dehydrator COPI_0000243 +2 Edit →
Demister COPI_0000244 +1 Edit →
Densitometer COPI_0000245 +1 Edit →
Detector COPI_0000246 +2 Edit →
Dew Point Analyser COPI_0000247 Edit →
Diaphragm Actuator COPI_0000248 Edit →
Diaphragm Pump COPI_0000249 Edit →
Diaphragm Valve COPI_0000108 Edit →
Diesel Engine COPI_0000250 +1 Edit →
Differential Pressure Gauge COPI_0000109 Edit →
Differential Pressure Measuring Element COPI_0000251 Edit →
Differential Pressure Switch COPI_0000252 Edit →
Differential Pressure Transmitter COPI_0000110 +1 Edit →
Diffuser COPI_0000253 +2 Edit →
Display COPI_0000254 Edit →
Distillation Column COPI_0000255 +1 Edit →
Diverter COPI_0000256 +3 Edit →
Double Block And Bleed Valve COPI_0000111 Edit →
Down Hole Safety Valve COPI_0000112 Edit →
Drill Bit COPI_0000723 Edit →
Drill String Edit →
Drive Shaft COPI_0000257 Edit →
Dryer COPI_0000258 +1 Edit →
Eductor COPI_0000259 +2 Edit →
Electric Actuator COPI_0000260 Edit →
Electric Generator COPI_0000261 Edit →
Electric Motor COPI_0000113 Edit →
Electrical Cable Edit →
Electrical Connection COPI_0000262 Edit →
Electrical Connector COPI_0000263 Edit →
Electrical Switch COPI_0000724 Edit →
Emergency Shut Down Valve COPI_0000114 Edit →
Enclosure Edit →
Engine COPI_0000264 Edit →
Evaporator Edit →
Expansion Joint COPI_0000265 +3 Edit →
Fan COPI_0000115 +2 Edit →
Filter COPI_0000081 +1 Edit →
Filter Cartridge COPI_0000266 +1 Edit →
Filter Element COPI_0000267 Edit →
Filter Medium COPI_0000725 Edit →
Filter Press COPI_0000268 +1 Edit →
Finned Tube COPI_0000726 Edit →
Finned Tube Heat Exchanger COPI_0000269 +1 Edit →
Fired Heater COPI_0000270 Edit →
Flame Arrestor COPI_0000271 Edit →
Flame Detector COPI_0000272 +2 Edit →
Flange COPI_0000273 +3 Edit →
Flare COPI_0000274 +3 Edit →
Flare Tip COPI_0000275 Edit →
Flash Drum COPI_0000276 Edit →
Flexible Riser COPI_0000277 Edit →
Flow Element COPI_0000116 Edit →
Flow Indicator COPI_0000117 Edit →
Flow Measuring Element COPI_0000082 Edit →
Flow Meter COPI_0000278 Edit →
Flow Modification Accessory COPI_0000083 Edit →
Flow Switch COPI_0000279 +1 Edit →
Flow Transmitter COPI_0000118 +1 +1 Edit →
Flowline COPI_0000280 +2 Edit →
Fluid Port Edit →
Furnace COPI_0000281 Edit →
Fuse COPI_0000282 +1 Edit →
Gas Chromatograph COPI_0000753 Edit →
Gas Cyclone Separator COPI_0000283 +1 Edit →
Gas Detecting Measuring Element COPI_0000727 Edit →
Gas Detector COPI_0000284 +2 Edit →
Gas Engine COPI_0000285 Edit →
Gas Turbine COPI_0000286 Edit →
Gasket COPI_0000287 Edit →
Gate Control Valve COPI_0000119 Edit →
Gate Valve COPI_0000120 +1 +1 Edit →
Gauge Edit →
Gear Casing COPI_0000288 Edit →
Gear Pump COPI_0000289 Edit →
Gear Wheel COPI_0000290 Edit →
Gearbox COPI_0000121 Edit →
Globe Control Valve COPI_0000122 Edit →
Globe Valve COPI_0000123 +1 Edit →
Globe Valve Body COPI_0000291 Edit →
Gravity Separator COPI_0000292 Edit →
Header COPI_0000293 Edit →
Heat Exchanger COPI_0000092 +1 Edit →
Heat Transfer Plate COPI_0000294 Edit →
Heater COPI_0000124 Edit →
Hopper COPI_0000295 +3 Edit →
Hose COPI_0000296 +1 Edit →
Housing COPI_0000297 Edit →
Humidity Analyser COPI_0000125 Edit →
Hydraulic Actuator COPI_0000298 Edit →
Hydraulic Motor COPI_0000299 Edit →
Hydraulic Pump COPI_0000300 Edit →
Hydrocyclone COPI_0000301 +2 Edit →
Ignitor Edit →
Impeller COPI_0000302 +2 Edit →
In-Line Filter COPI_0000126 +1 Edit →
Incinerator COPI_0000303 Edit →
Indicator COPI_0000127 +1 +3 Edit →
Injection Pump COPI_0000304 Edit →
Injection Well COPI_0000305 +3 Edit →
Input Shaft COPI_0000306 Edit →
Instrument COPI_0000091 Edit →
Kettle Reboiler COPI_0000307 Edit →
Knock Out Drum COPI_0000308 Edit →
Level Element COPI_0000128 Edit →
Level Indicator COPI_0000129 Edit →
Level Sight Glass COPI_0000130 Edit →
Level Switch COPI_0000309 Edit →
Level Transmitter COPI_0000131 +1 Edit →
Lifting Device Edit →
Limit Switch COPI_0000132 Edit →
Load Cell COPI_0000310 +2 Edit →
Lubricator Edit →
Manifold COPI_0000311 +1 +4 Edit →
Manual Actuator COPI_0000312 Edit →
Manual Valve COPI_0000133 Edit →
Master Valve COPI_0000728 Edit →
Measuring Element COPI_0000573 Edit →
Mill COPI_0000313 +1 Edit →
Mixer COPI_0000314 +1 +2 Edit →
Moisture Meter COPI_0000760 Edit →
Motor COPI_0000315 +2 Edit →
Needle Valve COPI_0000134 +1 Edit →
Nozzle COPI_0000316 +1 Edit →
On-Off Control Valve COPI_0000135 Edit →
Orifice Plate COPI_0000136 Edit →
Output Shaft COPI_0000317 Edit →
Panel COPI_0000729 Edit →
Phase Sequence Meter COPI_0000137 +1 Edit →
Pig Launcher COPI_0000318 +3 Edit →
Pig Receiver COPI_0000319 +2 Edit →
Pig Trap COPI_0000320 +1 +1 Edit →
Pipe COPI_0000321 +1 Edit →
Pipe Bend COPI_0000322 +2 +1 Edit →
Pipe Cap COPI_0000762 Edit →
Pipe Elbow COPI_0000323 Edit →
Pipe Reducer COPI_0000324 +1 Edit →
Pipe Reducer Concentric COPI_0000765 Edit →
Pipe Tee COPI_0000325 +1 Edit →
Pipeline COPI_0000326 +3 Edit →
Piston COPI_0000730 Edit →
Piston Check Valve COPI_0000138 Edit →
Plate Heat Exchanger COPI_0000139 +3 Edit →
Plug Valve COPI_0000140 +1 Edit →
Pneumatic Actuator COPI_0000327 Edit →
Pneumatic Motor COPI_0000328 Edit →
Port COPI_0000329 Edit →
Position Transmitter COPI_0000330 +1 Edit →
Positive Displacement Pump COPI_0000331 Edit →
Power Transformer COPI_0000141 +1 +1 Edit →
Power Transformer Primary Winding COPI_0000332 Edit →
Power Transformer Secondary Winding COPI_0000333 Edit →
Pressure Element COPI_0000142 Edit →
Pressure Gauge COPI_0000143 +1 Edit →
Pressure Indicating Transmitter COPI_0000334 Edit →
Pressure Transmitter COPI_0000144 +2 Edit →
Pressure Vessel COPI_0000090 Edit →
Probe COPI_0000766 Edit →
Process Variable Transmitter COPI_0000769 Edit →
Pump COPI_0000072 +1 +1 Edit →
Pump Casing COPI_0000335 Edit →
Pump Shaft COPI_0000336 Edit →
Quick Acting Valve COPI_0000770 Edit →
Quick Connector COPI_0000773 Edit →
Reciprocating Pump COPI_0000337 +1 Edit →
Relay COPI_0000338 +1 +2 Edit →
Relief Valve COPI_0000145 +1 +1 Edit →
Restriction Orifice COPI_0000146 Edit →
Riser COPI_0000339 +1 +1 Edit →
Rotary Actuator COPI_0000340 Edit →
Rotary Pump COPI_0000341 Edit →
Rotor COPI_0000342 Edit →
Rupture Disc COPI_0000343 +1 Edit →
Safety Relief Valve COPI_0000147 Edit →
Safety Valve COPI_0000148 +1 +1 Edit →
Sample Bomb COPI_0000776 Edit →
Sample Cooler COPI_0000779 Edit →
Sample Vessel COPI_0000781 Edit →
Scraper COPI_0000344 +3 Edit →
Scrubber COPI_0000345 +3 Edit →
Seat COPI_0000080 Edit →
Self-Operating Valve COPI_0000149 Edit →
Separator COPI_0000084 +1 +2 +1 Edit →
Shaft COPI_0000346 Edit →
Shaker COPI_0000347 +2 Edit →
Shear Ram COPI_0000348 +2 Edit →
Sheave COPI_0000349 Edit →
Shell And Tube Heat Exchanger COPI_0000074 Edit →
Sight Glass COPI_0000085 Edit →
Silencer COPI_0000350 Edit →
Silo COPI_0000351 +1 Edit →
Siphon COPI_0000782 Edit →
Skid COPI_0000352 +2 Edit →
Solenoid Actuator COPI_0000353 Edit →
Solenoid Valve COPI_0000150 Edit →
Spacer COPI_0000354 +3 Edit →
Stack Edit →
Stator COPI_0000355 Edit →
Stator Winding COPI_0000731 Edit →
Storage Tank COPI_0000151 Edit →
Strainer COPI_0000152 +3 Edit →
Sump COPI_0000785 Edit →
Swing Check Valve COPI_0000153 Edit →
Switch Contact COPI_0000356 Edit →
Switchboard COPI_0000357 +1 Edit →
Temperature Element COPI_0000076 Edit →
Temperature Indicator COPI_0000154 Edit →
Temperature Measuring Element COPI_0000358 Edit →
Temperature Measuring Instrument - Bimetal COPI_0000786 Edit →
Temperature Transmitter COPI_0000155 +1 Edit →
Thermowell COPI_0000156 +2 Edit →
Thermowell Stem COPI_0000359 Edit →
Thin Plate COPI_0000360 Edit →
Threaded Pipe Cap COPI_0000787 Edit →
Three Way Valve COPI_0000788 Edit →
Three-Phase Separator COPI_0000361 Edit →
Tote Tank Edit →
Transducer COPI_0000362 +1 +2 Edit →
Transformer COPI_0000086 +1 Edit →
Transmitter COPI_0000157 +3 Edit →
Transmitter Housing COPI_0000363 Edit →
Tube Bundle COPI_0000732 Edit →
Tubing Bowl COPI_0000733 Edit →
Tubing Hanger COPI_0000364 +1 +1 Edit →
Tubing Head COPI_0000365 +2 Edit →
Turbine COPI_0000366 +1 Edit →
Umbilical COPI_0000367 +1 Edit →
Ups Unit COPI_0000368 Edit →
Vacuum Column COPI_0000369 Edit →
Valve COPI_0000077 Edit →
Valve Body COPI_0000078 Edit →
Valve Closure Member COPI_0000370 Edit →
Valve Seat COPI_0000371 Edit →
Valve Stem COPI_0000372 Edit →
Vessel COPI_0000158 Edit →
Vessel Head COPI_0000373 Edit →
Vessel Shell COPI_0000374 Edit →
Vibration Transmitter COPI_0000159 +1 Edit →
Wafer Check Valve COPI_0000160 Edit →
Well COPI_0000375 +1 +1 Edit →
Wellbore COPI_0000376 +1 Edit →
Wellhead COPI_0000377 +2 Edit →
Wing Valve COPI_0000734 Edit →
Wireline COPI_0000378 +1 Edit →
Divergence Types
T1 Categorical Placement
Different standards place the equipment under incompatible parent categories
T2 Granularity
One standard treats it as atomic; another decomposes into sub-classes
T3 Identity Criteria
Standards use different identity criteria: function-based vs topology-based vs property-based
T4 Topological vs. Mereological
One standard models material parts (mereological); another models topological segments
T5 Implicit Function
No standard formally axiomatizes the identity-giving function (universal)
Step → Divergence Mapping
StepReveals
1 — Identity-giving functionT5 T3
2 — GenusT1
3 — DifferentiaT3
4 — Necessary partsT2 T4
5 — Process signatureT5
✕
Resolution (ontologist notes)

Suggest a change

Opens a pre-filled GitHub issue on the COPI repo — nothing is sent until you submit it there.