Definition & axiom
⚠ Conflicts with the ISO 15926-4 primary definition
Label (EN)
double ball valve
Label (PT-BR)
Definition (EN)
Definition (PT-BR)
Semi-formal axiom (Aristotelian)
Axiom type
LLM classification basis: structure-based → ⊑
ISO 15926-4 individuates the concept by physical configuration: 'consisting of two BALL VALVEs in one housing'. The 'double isolation' it provides is a consequence of that configuration, and the same isolation capability is realised by other constructions (a single trunnion ball with two seats — the ISO 14313 DBB/DIB valve; a double block and bleed gate valve). Identity is therefore constructive.
Validation status
Why primitive (necessary only)
Reviewer notes
FOL theory & disjointness
First-order logic theory (generated)
Loading…
Disjoint with
▸
Expert review
Axiomatization steps
1
Identity-Giving Function
✓ done
FlowControlFunction → FlowControlProcess ⊑ FlowControl
▼
COPI-Core operation
FlowControl via process parent FlowControl
LLM rationale:
Reuse case (co-extensional): the genus Valve and the already-enriched siblings ball valve and double block and bleed valve all bear FlowControlFunction. 'Providing double isolation' is a structural redundancy of the closure (two ball valves in series in one housing), not a distinct function type — its realisation is still a flow control process in which flow is prevented. A new DoubleIsolationFunction subtype was considered and rejected: no already-enriched function for isolation exists as a genuine supertype, and minting one for a constructive type would break consistency with double block and bleed valve (id 161), which models the same capability under FlowControlFunction.
▸
Expert review
2
Genus Proximus
✓ done
BallValve · MaterialArtifact
▼
Genus (genus proximum)
Most specific superclass — may be a domain class like "Valve" or an IOF-Core root.
BFO/IOF-Core Root
bfo:Object branch
bfo:ObjectAggregate branch
bfo:ImmaterialEntity branch
LLM rationale:
Parent candidates from the source hierarchy: ARTEFACT and VALVE (enriched). BallValve (enriched, COPI_0000095) chosen as genus proximum after reviewer decision: every double ball valve satisfies the ISO 15926-4 BALL VALVE definition (a rotary valve using a ball closure pivoted 90 degrees to provide flow control), so it is a genuine subtype even though ISO 15926-4 asserts only VALVE as its parent. The 'consisting of two BALL VALVEs' clause describes its construction and is captured in the differentia. genus_bfo_root follows Valve/BallValve (MaterialArtifact).
▸
Expert review
3
Differentia Specifica
✓ done
(≥2 hasComponentPartAtAllTimes.BallValve) ⊓ ∃hasComponentPartAtAllTimes.Housing
▼
Conditions that distinguish
Double Ball Valve
from sibling classes under genus
BallValve.
Only what is not already entailed by the genus.
Differentia expression
Differentia (natural language)
LLM rationale:
Minimal conditions not entailed by BallValve (which already provides the ball closure member and FlowControlFunction): at least two ball valve components and the common housing that makes the arrangement one valve rather than two valves in series. Both are stated verbatim in the primary definition. The OWL axiom carries ∃hasComponentPartAtAllTimes.BallValve and ∃hasComponentPartAtAllTimes.Housing; the minimum cardinality (≥2) is stated in the FOL axiom only, because iof-core:hasComponentPartAtAllTimes is transitive (non-simple) and OWL 2 DL forbids cardinality restrictions on non-simple properties (ROBOT/HermiT rejects the ontology).
▸
Expert review
4
Necessary Parts
✓ done
BallValve, Housing
▼
Consider part-whole relations beyond subsumption:
hasComponentPartAtAllTimes (universal, structurally essential)
· hasComponentPartAtSomeTime (contingent, optional component)
LLM rationale:
BallValve (min 2) and Housing are both stated without hedge in the ISO 15926-4 primary definition. A bleed/vent valve between the balls is a DBB/DIB feature (ISO 14313:2007 4.7/4.8; Velan ABV; Wermac), not stated genus-wide, so it is not listed.
▸
Expert review
5
Process Participation Signature ⟨I, O, T⟩
✓ done
PortionOfFluid → PortionOfFluid
▼
Inputs (I)
Outputs (O)
Transformation (T)
LLM rationale:
The primary definition names isolation as the purpose ('providing double isolation'), so flow_isolation rather than flow_regulation. The same fluid participant enters and leaves, so input and output share type. A bleed output is omitted because not every double ball valve has a bleed means.
▸
Expert review
More
Alternative labels
none
▼
Synonyms / alternative labels (comma-separated) — skos:altLabel
Language auto-detected on export (PT if the label contains accents, EN otherwise).
Properties as BFO qualities
no CFIHOS/DEXPI properties
▼
No CFIHOS/DEXPI properties found for this cluster.
Custom axioms
none
▼
Axioms not produced by the pipeline. Each is appended verbatim as an
rdfs:subClassOf restriction on Double Ball Valve.
Write the restriction block in Turtle syntax (without the leading
rdfs:subClassOf).
Example: [ owl:onProperty :hasPart ; owl:someValuesFrom :Wellhead ]
Cross-standard divergences
none detected yet
▼
Click "Detect divergences" to analyse cross-standard disagreements for this cluster.